By Jeff Holroyd
Part III of Series
The Hotel Jamestown is an architectural and historically important asset serving as a mixed-use facility for housing and commercial activity for the greater Jamestown area. Preservation and restoration is essential to maintaining the building’s architectural authenticity, improve energy efficiency, ensuring long-term viability for its continued use by the community.
The Hotel opened at a cost of $1,500,000 with a New Years Eve gala in 1924. Featuring 300 rooms on 10 floors with 250 baths and circulating ice water in all rooms. Also included, 100 offices and 6 storefronts, a convention hall, ballroom, banquet hall, Pompian room, and a moderately priced cafeteria. Now 102 years later, the old girl is in dire need of a facelift.
In the original DRI 2.0 Application, the project focused on critical exterior repairs to the historic Hotel Jamestown, along with the acquisition and renovation of the Brick City convenience store to create a shared and accessible entrance to the hotel, the Crystal Ballroom, and the proposed market-rate apartments created with the adaptive reuse of the currently vacant office space on each floor. The Brick City store was acquired by another entity, so the Jamestown Housing Authority revised the project scope.

Key elements of this revised project now include:
Restore and stabilize deteriorated portions of the Hotel’s exterior masonry, to ensure the building remains viable for years to come. This restoration is a vital first phase in the Jamestown Housing Authority’s long-term strategy for the adaptive reuse and revitalization of the currently vacant portions of the building.
The anticipated longer-term goal of the Jamestown Housing Authority is to repurpose the approximately 2,000 square feet of vacant office space on each of the 10 floors into market rate apartments. within the DRI’s stated goal of having projects completed in a 3–5-year time frame.
This project will serve an ongoing community need as demand for this type of housing continues to increase. Development of new market-rate housing has demonstrated a viable market downtown, at least initially on a smaller scale. More than 60 market-rate apartments have been recently developed, including: 44 units at the Wellman Building on 3rd Street and 10 units at the Willow Bay Theater, 3 blocks east on 3rd Street. These housing units were typically filled by those in the medical community, engineers, temporary corporate housing, and other young professionals who have relocated to the area.
The City of Jamestown has demonstrated a strong commitment to enacting policies that align with state and regional priorities, enhance livability and provide opportunities for sustained economic growth. The city actively implements a comprehensive plan to guide growth and development prioritizing housing and economic development. Additional laws have been enacted that further address housing and economic development priorities; including a Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan that aligns with HUD funding requirements and efforts and set strategic objectives.
A Rich and Colorful History
The Hotel, now most famously known locally as having hosted hometown comedy icon Lucille Ball, for several functions as she returned home for various affairs. Prior to the Lucy era, during the 1950’s the Hotel had a colorful history of top social and civic functions. During those years, some of the leading figures in every facet of life, politics, business, entertainment, and sports had signed their name to the hostelry’s register.
The Temple Hesed Abrahams Sports Night was an annual event that was attended by upwards of 1,000 people in the Hotel’s Crystal Ballroom. The long list of sports stars and celebrities includes; boxing legends Joe Louis, and Jersey Joe Walcott, baseball legends; Jackie Robinson, Pete Rose, Mickey Mantle, Roberto Clemente, Brooks Robinson, Bob Gibson, Willie Stargill, Whitey Ford, Roger Maris, just to name a few.
Football legends included; Jim Brown, Gale Sayers, Joe Paterno, Ted Marchibroda, Lou Groza, Leroy Kelly, Franco Harris, Rocky Blier, et al.
Sports Announcers/Writers include; Howard Cosell(twice), Mel Allen, Pat Summerall, Walt Michaels, and Dick Young.
Another memorable night occurred in February 1956 when a packed audience jammed the spacious Crystal Ballroom for a dance honoring the community’s own Lucille Ball, here for the world premiere of her latest picture, Forever Darling.
The Hotel Jamestown’s DRI 2.0 project request of $1,500,000 out of a total project cost of $1,800,000 will contribute to Phase I of the building’s adaptive reuse of the currently vacant office space by securing the building’s exterior masonry. The Jamestown Housing Authority can then focus their resources on repurposing the vacant office space into market-rate apartments, increasing the housing stock in that underserved market segment.
